Why Hope Is Not a Cargo Theft Strategy with Scott Cornell
Episode Transcript

Scott Cornell has a simple rule for the moment your stomach drops on a load: act like it’s a theft. If it turns out to be nothing, your team just ran a free drill. If it is a theft, you saved hours you can’t get back, and with cargo crime those hours decide whether the freight comes back at all.

I sat down with Scott, Executive Vice President at SPG Cargo & Logistics and chair of TAPA Americas, for the CargoRex Cargo Theft and Freight Fraud Prevention guide. He walks through how strategic theft grew from about three percent of all cargo theft before 2020 to roughly thirty percent now, why so much of it lands on freight brokers, and why he wants the industry to stop posting its playbook on LinkedIn.

This conversation is one of six interviews in the guide, and you’re hearing it in full.

In this episode

  • Straight theft versus strategic theft, and why the second one leaves so many victims unsure how they were hit
  • The commodities thieves want most, from food and beverage to copper
  • Why good process comes first and technology works best on top of it
  • How small carriers can win more freight by making verification easy
  • How to build and test a theft response plan before you need it

Links from the episode

Related categories on CargoRex

Related episodes

—————————————–

THANK YOU TO OUR SPONSORS!

SPI Logistics has been a Day 1 supporter of this podcast which is why we’re proud to promote them in every episode. During that time, we’ve gotten to know the team and their agents to confidently say they are the best home for freight agents in North America for 40 years and counting. Listen to past episodes to hear why.

CargoRex is the search engine for the logistics industry—connecting LSPs with the right tools, services, events, and creators to explore, discover, and evolve.

Digital Dispatch maximizes and manages your #1 sales tool with a website that establishes trust and builds rock-solid relationships with your leads and customers. 

Show Transcript

See full episode transcriptTranscript is autogenerated by AI

SPEAKER_00 0:37

Uh, welcome into another episode of our Cargo Rex Cargo Crime Guide series. That's a whole mouthful of words, but basically, we're going to be tackling cargo crime in this conversation with none other than Scott Cornell. He is the executive vice president at SPG Cargo and Logistics. And Scott, welcome to IANA. Welcome to the show. So happy to have you finally.

SPEAKER_01 1:00

Yeah, no, it's great to be here. Thank you for inviting me. I'm I'm looking forward to the discussion. Happy to be at IANA. I think it's a great conference, a great organization. So it's fun.

SPEAKER_00 1:08

So I we were just talking before I hit record, and I was talking about, you know, sort of the history of trains and, you know, trying to learn more about intermodal freight and things like that. I when I think of cargo crime with trains, you think of like the old school days of you know bandits on horses that are, you know, running up.

SPEAKER_01 1:29

They're just not riding horses anymore. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00 1:31

So so what does it look like today? Well, what does modern cargo crime look like today?

SPEAKER_01 1:36

Uh in in the intermodal space or in general?

SPEAKER_00 1:38

In general. Let's go high level and then we'll go next.

SPEAKER_01 1:41

Sure. So cargo theft has drastically changed in the United States over the last six years or so. Post 2020, we've seen some really significant changes in the cargo theft environment and landscape here in the United States, in particular with massive increases, not only in the overall cargo theft numbers, but really what's caught the industry kind of on their heels is the massive increase in strategic cargo theft. Prior to 2020, strategic cargo theft represented about 3% of all cargo theft, and now it's at about the 30% mark, give or take, depending on the quarter, everything like that. But um that massive increase first of all happened very quickly. It was really between 21 and 24. We saw a 93% increase in overall cargo theft, but a 1475% increase in that strategic theft uh area. And in particular, it's problematic because it attacks the intermediary space. And the intermediary space traditionally, prior to this massive increase, was not that they didn't deal with cargo theft at all, but they dealt with it the least. And usually when they were dealing with it, it really wasn't from them because strategic theft, again, was 3% or less. So usually when a when a freight broker was dealing with cargo theft, it was because the trucking company that they hired, the driver went into the truck stop, came out, tractor and trailer were gone, or you know, something was stolen as with a fictitious pickup at the dock of the shipper, which would have been on the shipper for loading the right the wrong carrier. So they didn't really have to deal with it other than on an ancillary basis. Now you have 30% of all cargo theft directed squarely at the intermediary space. And the other thing that's important to understand about strategic theft is whereas straight theft is very much straightforward, which is why it's called that, and there's only a few methods, and those methods are old school for the most part. Strategic theft has 25 to 30 different methods, and a lot of them look similar, and sometimes it's a crossover of one or two methods. And so what I find a lot of times when somebody calls me about a cargo theft is they don't really know exactly how they were stolen from, they just know they were stolen from. So I spend my first contact with them just trying to ferret out exactly what method they were hit with, and then we can kind of go from there. So big changes, lots of confusion in the industry. And I think that if you ask the average person, they would tell you that strategic theft is the majority of cargo theft because it feels like it because of the mass confusion and the massive increase, but it's still only that 30% mark.

SPEAKER_00 4:27

What makes up the rest of it? Is it just opportunity?

SPEAKER_01 4:29

Yeah, no, it's straight theft. It's still organized rings, still organized crews, but straight theft is just where they physically go out and steal it. So they physically go out, whether it's on the rail, which we're going to talk about, right? Or whether it's a tractor and a trailer parked at a truck stop, or uh uh, you know, in the yard stage to go out on another day, things like that. So they're just physically going out and stealing it. Pilfridge, too, we would include in there, where they open the rear doors, take two, three pallets. So straight theft is still the majority of all cargo theft. It's just that that's been around for so long and the methods are so consistent that it's really not shaking the foundation of the supply chain as much as that strategic theft category is.

SPEAKER_00 5:11

Now, is that 30% that you're talking about? Is that more high value freight? Uh, or are you talking about data centered, you know, those supplies, those getting targeted?

SPEAKER_01 5:20

Yeah, so the the one of the things that we know about the strategic theft is that they can really dial in a little bit better uh sometimes than the straight theft. Now, you know, for straight theft, we see a lot of surveillance on certain distribution centers and warehouses and following drivers out. And they know what's, you know, generally moving in and out of those distribution centers and warehouses that they're watching. Sometimes it's obvious, meaning it's labeled, you know, with the brand. So they know exactly what's coming out. But when you talk about that strategic theft method, they can really dial into are we looking for technology, are we looking for clothing, are we looking for meat and seafood? Are we looking for energy drinks? And they can kind of pick it off of the loadboards. And because they're doing it remotely, meaning they're they're overseas, most of these big uh most of these big strategic theft rings are based overseas. So because they're doing it overseas, they can send somebody to go pick it up wherever it is. They don't have to be around the ports, they don't have to be around the distribution centers. They can just send somebody to go wherever the load is. So

SPEAKER_00 6:24

really it's gone global, it's not regional.

SPEAKER_01 6:26

Yeah, that's the biggest part of the change, right? Is that most of the strategic theft and even some of the straight theft is being conducted from overseas. The, you know, the head of the state, head of the snake, so to speak, is overseas, and the people here are just boots on the ground.

SPEAKER_00 6:40

And so is it concentrated in any certain area of the world, or is it, you know, where is it maybe 70% in Eastern Europe or South America or

SPEAKER_01 6:50

So we see, you know, um Eastern European countries, we see Middle Eastern countries, we see Southeast Asian countries. I mean, you name it. It's it's it's yeah, it's all over, even some European too. You know, if you look at there's a couple of different um there's a couple of different resources out there that will give you the top five countries and the top ten countries and things like that. And I can I can forward you those. I I prefer not to zero in on specific countries or anything like that, because I feel like then sometimes the baby gets thrown out with the bathwater. And I'm not a fan of that.

SPEAKER_00 7:24

Yeah, that that makes it especially in today's internet, you know, where where anything can be sort of misconstrued and and then used again, and then you're you're losing sight of the goal is to stop it, is to prevent. People

SPEAKER_01 7:35

ask me all the time who are, you know, who are cargo thieves? And I just say they're just thieves, they're just cargo thieves. I mean, you you you ask, and I can find you a cargo thief to, you know, in anywhere, basically, because cargo theft is a global issue.

SPEAKER_00 7:48

And I think it always has been because I I was I'm reading a book right now because the Splendid Exchange that talked about how these merchants would just sleep on their cargo in order to avoid people stealing it. And that that's how they kept their cargo secured. But the merchant actually slept on the cargo.

SPEAKER_01 8:03

Yeah.

SPEAKER_00 8:04

So let's take it back to well, well, I guess uh are there specific commodities that you're seeing? You mentioned over the last six years it's changed drastically. Are there specific commodities that are being targeted?

SPEAKER_01 8:13

Yeah, food and beverage. So when you look at the buckets, when you look at the big buckets, food and beverage is your number one. Metals uh have moved into number two just for a quarter. But in general, what we see is the top three are food and beverage, uh household goods, and electronics. For uh one of the, I think the most recent quarter, metals moved into number two, putting household goods at three and electronics at four. I don't think that's something that'll stick on a consistent basis. But the fact that metals is even pushing in that top three, even if it's for a brief period of time, is significant. This is probably the longest stretch we've seen on metals. Usually metal theft will go a year or two. This is we're we're coming up on three and a half, probably getting close to four years of metal being targeted. But when you look at the big buckets, it's that food and beverage, household goods, and electronics. Now, if you dial into specific commodities, copper's gonna be your number one when you get down to that one specific commodity. Tires is up there in the top three. It's listed under automotive, but it's usually tires. Uh, when you're in the food and beverage category, it's usually non-alcoholic beverages, which is energy drinks. And then it's meats and seafoods, frozen meats and seafoods, and then it's alcoholic beverages, and then snack foods and electronics, it's going to be televisions, gaming consoles, cell phones, things like that. So, you know, you have the big buckets and then you dial down into specific commodities, and it can change the order that you think might exist.

SPEAKER_00 9:43

And then is that as exclusive to the United States, or do you kind of see those similarities in buckets across the world?

SPEAKER_01 9:49

Yeah, I would that's a great question. I think there's usually pretty good consistency in those buckets. Food and beverage is usually number one pretty much anywhere. Um, you know, I I always kind of say, John Paul Getty said if you're gonna go into business, sell something that people want, need and use every day, well, cargo thieves are in business and they're stealing something that people want, need, and use every day, which is the food and beverage commodity.

SPEAKER_00 10:11

And there's no evidence when it's

SPEAKER_01 10:13

no evidence. I you know I used to tell people that they it's an ideal commodity for them because the evidence is consumed, right? Or it spoils, it's very hard to trace. Um, you know, and even you know, as a cargo theft investigator, if I were to go out, if if you have a load of frozen meat stolen and I go out and investigate it on your behalf, if I recover it for you, what are you going to do with it? Right? So they know this about us, they know this about the industry, and they know that some stuff won't get pursued as hard as others or for as long as others.

SPEAKER_00 10:44

Yeah, because I would imagine there's serial numbers on TVs and electronics, and so those are easily traced.

SPEAKER_01 10:50

All those things ping on the internet, right? Now, almost every electronic device you can buy, my refrigerator pings on the internet now, right? So I'm you know, so

SPEAKER_00 10:58

can't escape it.

SPEAKER_01 11:00

Almost anything you're gonna steal electronically is going to pop on the internet at some point. You know, uh several months ago I was uh pursuing a load of really popular, I won't name the brand, but popular earbuds. Um not the brand that you're probably thinking of, but but a popular brand. And within six or seven days, they were pinging in Europe. So it moves that quickly, right? But but the fact remains that it's electronic and I can get a ping on them. Right. So

SPEAKER_00 11:31

when you say you can get a ping on them, I'd imagine you probably want to, I guess, walk a fine line of consulting people on what to do with cargo crime, but also not tipping off the thieves of what the strategies are, or is it kind of just a wild, wild west, right?

SPEAKER_01 11:46

No, another great question. I always say, I openly and very vervently say, you know, stop posting your solutions on LinkedIn, please, to the industry, right? We uh we have a tendency as an industry to want to collaborate, which is great, and I encourage that collaboration. But when you want to be the first one to post it on LinkedIn or post it somewhere else, you're just putting it out there for the bad guys. They're monitoring us, they're watching these posts, they're looking at these posts, and we see it, we see them adjust. When we see solutions get publicized, you know, pretty uh regularly, we'll we'll see the bad guys pivot and adjust around those solutions very quickly. So I think as a whole, the industry has to stop doing that. I think, you know, you come together, you know, I sit as the chairman of TAPA Americas as well. And we're a nonprofit organization that creates supply chain security standards for the industry, but we also hold two major conferences where pretty much everybody who's in the supply chain security business comes, right? And when you when you come there, that's the place to talk about your solutions. That's the place to collaborate. But to go on social media and put your solutions out is I always equate it, I coach football, right? And it would be like me sending my playbook to the opposing team, you know, a week before the game.

SPEAKER_00 13:02

Exactly. And I was wondering how you balance the the information exchange and and helping others, but I imagine you do this in person.

SPEAKER_01 13:10

Yeah, it's more in-person, more direct. You know, uh in particular, I spend a lot of time with my clients. My team spends a lot of time with our clients, and you know, we're either flying out to see them and we we sit down with them and we we evaluate their process and we give them suggestions or we teach them techniques or we introduce them to different solutions or technology, you name it, or we're on a Teams meeting, or we're on a phone call, or we're giving them something written that goes directly to them and is, you know, proprietary to us and them. And I think I think for the industry, it's important to keep communication at that level at this point because we know that they're watching everything that we do.

SPEAKER_00 14:41

And so with tech, I mean, you you've kind of hinted at it, especially over the last six years, there's been just an explosion of technology within logistics. And so everybody's trying to navigate what they should have, what their tech stack should look like, and then you add AI on top of it all. How are companies, without divulging, you know, the the secret sauce, but how are companies tackling this?

SPEAKER_01 15:04

The first thing I would say is I think there's too much of a rush to go directly to technology as the solution, right? And I think that's I think that's a societal thing. We're just so hooked on technology that we think there's always a solution somewhere in the tech. And I think tech is very valuable to the solutions uh that are out there. But I think everything should start with the human element. So when I work with my clients, the you know, we we take a a three-layered approach. The first layer is you know, good process and procedures. We talk about this probably at nauseum to the industry, has probably heard me say it over and over again. Which if you don't have those good processing procedures in place first, if I use TAPA again as an example, TAPA puts out standards, you know, supply chain security standards. So if I use the freight broker security requirement standard, it gives you a great foundation of process that you can institute. And then after that, you're going to add things like security devices or you're going to add things like technology. Well, that technology is now going to be much more effective because it's enhancing a foundational process that you have internally. A lot of times there's some great tech solutions out there, uh, especially now around the strategic theft category. But when I see it fail, quite often it fails not because the technology fails, but because the user fails to use it appropriately or use it consistently or use it in the right way. And so that goes back to that, hey, you have to have a good foundation of your process, and then you enhance that process with the technology. And quite often, then the technology gets the blame for the fail when it's really not the technology's fault because it's just a tool in the hand of the user, and the user has to use it right.

SPEAKER_00 16:51

And so the the with the human element, I mean, I I think it was NGM hotels two years ago. They got taken down by someone who was just pretending. They went to their LinkedIn profile, they found out the information for the IT security person. Uh, they phoned into the customer service line and were able to get access just by using public LinkedIn information. And the person on the phone just didn't do their proper due diligence, and they were able to get in and shut down all of the casinos in Vegas in

SPEAKER_01 17:19

hours. I mean, uh, Gary Thomas, who's on my team, he's he's well known in the industry, he's uh great. Uh he's one of the experts that we have out there in the industry around cargo theft. And he always jokes that he and I are just going to start a side business where we just Google things for people because so many times a theft will come across his desk or my desk or our desk, you know, uh together, where he just immediately Googles the information and finds eight or nine red flags that would have alerted anybody to hey, don't use this carrier, don't use this person's not real, this entity's not real, or this entity, you know, is a hot shot hauler. They're not what you think they are, they can't haul this type of commodity. They work in upstate New York, you're moving a commodity in Southern California, right? And he just Googles it and he swears by it. And I think that's part of that human element. And he and I preach that together all the time is you know, keep that human element. Sometimes we're working with a client who will say, Well, you know, we subscribed to X, Y, and Z technology or this service, and so we reduced our carrier vetting team. You know, we it allowed us to reduce our carrier vetting team by three people. And our response to that is always, no, no, no, no. That's the wrong direction, right? You keep keep those numbers, keep that human touch, but enhance their effectiveness. Now, maybe you don't need to go hire as many as you had planned, but don't reduce it, right? Keep that human touch and and and have that interact with the tech in the proper way.

SPEAKER_00 18:48

And then with with uh just AI being able to mass send you know the phishing emails and phone calls, and how much have you seen that that that enhances an already big problem? Yeah,

SPEAKER_01 19:00

AI has, you know, will AI change cargo theft has been the big question for probably the last three years. And the answer is, you know, the the easy and dry answer is certainly, certainly it's going to enhance it. But I've always said ultimately it's going to be AI versus AI. And it's going to be who has the better AI user, who's better at using the AI. I think the examples that you included in your question are perfect. We see a lot of use of AI for mass emails, mass phishing emails, mass social engineering attempts. Uh, we've even seen incidents where they use it to uh put an accent, like a regional accent on their voice. So if they're, you know, talking to somebody in Tennessee, they'll use AI to put a Tennessee accent on so it sounds familiar, right? Or something like that. So we're certainly seeing the use of AI. Has it really, you know, 3X or 5X the cargo thieves' ability to steal? I think it's it's certainly had an impact on the volume. It certainly had an impact, especially when you talk about that email phishing and the social engineering. How many times we see cases where it started with somebody clicking on a link that they shouldn't have clicked on? It certainly had a big impact in that area. And I th but again, I think that's probably easier said than done, but train your staff. You know, you you really have to train your staff. And I think that's an important point, too, if we could, is to talk about all too often at a company we see a concentration of expertise or knowledge on cargo theft, meaning there's a security manager and their team, or a risk manager and their team, and and they get all the education, they get all the expertise on it, and then they're trying to share that expertise out. And my approach with my clients is no, educate the frontline people as much as you educate those experts because they're the ones that are actually releasing the freight. They're the ones that are hiring the carrier, they're the ones that are at the dock door at the warehouse. And when we, you know, you know, I'll go out and train my clients' entire staff. And within a week or two, I'll get these great emails of, hey, we we found, you know, we we found three fake IDs at the at the dock door last week because of the training you guys came and gave and things like that. So I think training that frontline staff, the people that are actually dealing with the cargo and assigning the loads or releasing the loads at the dock, that's who really has to gain the expertise around cargo theft because they're your front line of defense.

SPEAKER_00 21:27

And I think yeah, I heard you mention too with the sales teams that this is an incredible sales opportunity. I was at um a TMSA's conference, uh, Transportation Marketing Sales Association, and Cassandra Gaines was up, you know, giving a talk, and she asked everyone to raise their hand of who is marketing their security, that they that they take cargo theft, you know, seriously. And uh are they doing you know uh client reports and you know case studies and things like that. Two people, I think, raised their hand that they were marketing this.

SPEAKER_01 21:57

Yeah.

SPEAKER_00 21:57

And so for like the marketing and the salespeople too, like it's it's so important for them to be able to talk to their customers about how they're gonna protect their freight.

SPEAKER_01 22:05

100%. I I asked that question, been asking that question for years when I when I go out and speak, and I think it's an important question to ask because listen, I understand that the sales team is trying to gain business. They're trying to to increase business. And so they have a tough assignment, right? I need to increase business, but I also need to be worried about theft and everything like that. I think the first thing I would say is there needs to be great communication between that sales team and the security team or the risk team and everybody else that's involved in the process. You can't have your sales team go out and sign a contract tomorrow that is going to commit you to move pharmaceuticals in some of the worst cargo theft areas in the country and not talk to your security team about what will that entail and what will our costs be to move that effectively without having a theft. So you have to have that internal communication. I think that's critical. But the other part of it is when you're asking the sales team to go out and increase business, but also be concerned about cargo theft, do exactly what you're saying. Market the fact that you are better than your peers at protecting the freight that you're about to sign a deal on, right? That you can not only offer great transportation services, but you can offer secure transportation services. And the load's going to get there and it's not going to be stolen, and you're not going to have this big mess. I talk often about it's a pay me now or pay me later type of. Of a situation, meaning you can take the extra time up front to do things right. And a lot of times the pushback I get is, hey, we're trying to move freight. And I get, okay. What's going to slow you down more? An extra five minutes to vet a carrier or to go through a security plan or something like that, or theft. What's going to slow you down more? I promise you that theft is going to bring you to a grinding halt. And it's going to do it for weeks. And

SPEAKER_00 23:57

you're going to lose a customer.

SPEAKER_01 23:57

And you're going to lose a customer.

SPEAKER_00 23:59

And so you have to make sure that you're doing this due diligence. I want to go into the United States in particular, and maybe even North America, since we're, you

unknown 24:07

know,

SPEAKER_00 24:07

we're in recording this in California right now. We're very close to, you know, the border with Mexico. And so how is uh, I guess, uh, cargo theft and crime evolving in the United States? Is it still kind of the hot spots that we saw during maybe, you know, COVID when it was, you know, these trains are just, you know, the doors are getting opened, and people are just, you know, maybe a crime of opportunity in that case. But are we still seeing these hot spots in, you know, uh on the West Coast, maybe Miami, along the border? What's happening inside the North America?

SPEAKER_01 24:37

Absolutely. I mean, the the theft is always going to be where the freight is, but that has changed on several different levels. When it comes to straight theft, again, where they physically go out and steal it, we're always going to see more of that around those traditional hotspots. What do those traditional spots, hotspots, have in common? They're usually ports. They're usually like if you look at California, you know, fifth largest economy on the planet, Texas, fastest growing economy in the United States, Florida, big growing economy. So they have ports, they have strong economies, they have high population density, they have arterial highways, they have industrial centers, things like that, right? So those are the commonalities you have. And when you're talking about straight theft, that's where the concentration is going to be for straight theft because physically, if you're physically going to go out and get it, that's where the most the majority of it is going to be is around those hotspots. So we still see those traditional hotspots. California number one, New Jersey recently took the number two spot from Texas, Texas number three. For about three years, Texas has been number two. I think Texas will come back in at that number two spot. But we see that after California, we see all the other positions shift over time. We've seen Florida at number two, Texas at number two, New Jersey at number two. So that'll that'll always fluctuate a little bit. California's the one consistent victim of their own success with that. They have more law enforcement. You

unknown 26:00

know,

SPEAKER_01 26:00

I joke with my friends in California about being number one for cargo theft for so long. But the tree, the truth of it is major ports all up and down the state, fifth largest economy, like I said, victim of their own success in that sense. So California's consistently number one. The others will change. Now, when you talk about strategic theft, this goes back to your question earlier, they don't care if it's near the ports. So, with the massive increase in strategic theft, we've seen cargo theft spread into what we would consider non-traditional areas. So now, you know, if it's a commodity they want and it's in Cheyenne, Wyoming, they can target it in Cheyenne, Wyoming. They don't have to care whether it's near a port city or not. So when you talked about some of these tech loads that we've seen, they'll go after those tech loads no matter where they're coming from. We've seen them come out of Salt Lake City, we've seen them come out of Texas, we've seen them come out of, you know, the upper Midwest. So that strategic theft, those strategic theft methods allow them to dial into the freight that they want no matter where it is. So when you look at the strategic theft heat map, it just looks vastly different because it's all across the country. When you look at a straight theft map, it's more concentrated in those traditional areas.

SPEAKER_00 27:13

And does it that does the mode matter? I mean, we're we're at IANA, you

unknown 27:17

know,

SPEAKER_00 27:17

we're talking, you know, a little bit about trains and intermodal freight and

SPEAKER_01 27:21

it it does to some extent. I would say that um, you know, we still certainly see intermodal loads targeted in both methods, both straight and strategic theft. But when you talk about it on the rail, you know, that's obviously a ton of intermodal on there. And I think it was last year. Don't quote my numbers exactly, but you know, I was in Washington and I I was meeting with a congressional committee and the rail was there, and I think they reported the top three rails alone reported 65,000 thefts in 2025, and they thought that was underreported, and that was just the top three. So the rail has a real issue with cargo theft, not of their own doing. And I would tell you that I know several people that work on the rail and they're working as hard as anybody I know every day. But when you look at the task in front of them with thousands of miles of track in the middle of nowhere, and you know, these these thieves that are hitting the trains are hitting them out in the middle of the desert, Needles, California, you know, Mojave Desert in in Arizona, uh, you know, middle of nowhere, New Mexico. I mean, these are really tough geographical areas for the rail to cover, let alone solve the problem. So they're working very hard at it. They've thrown a ton of assets at it, they've thrown a ton of money at it. Um, they're they have special units, they're using drone technology, they're using all sorts of stuff. And I think they're doing yeoman's work, but they have a hard task in front of them.

SPEAKER_00 28:51

That's interesting about the drones part, because you can, you know, obviously they're being used in a variety of different ways, but you know, from rescue operations to now to to cargo prevention or cargo theft prevention.

SPEAKER_01 29:03

It's really uh yeah, I mean, it's really identifying it, right? So you're you're almost in a response position because the drone is going to spot a theft in in process. So at that point, it's more of a response type thing. I guess you know, you could look at it as prevention if they're patrolling up and down, they see somebody approaching or something like that, but I think it's it's more so to identify where the thefts are occurring and they're not

SPEAKER_00 29:26

approaching on horseback.

SPEAKER_01 29:28

Not that I'm not that I'm aware of. No.

SPEAKER_00 29:31

I don't know if a horse will ping in a you know in a different part of the state or whatever. Um well, since you talked about it or mentioned it, what happens when you suspect something is is fishy? I think you I heard you mention that it's a spidey sense. Um so that you know, having that good spidey sense to prevent it, but then what happens when you suspect that something has happened? What what does that action plan look like?

SPEAKER_01 29:55

You know, um there's always I think in when it comes to cargo theft, hope is not your friend. And what do I mean by that? I mean the minute you get that spidey sense, the minute your stomach starts to twinge just a little bit where you think something could be fishy here, but you hope it's not. Don't go with hope. Hope

SPEAKER_00 30:21

is not a strategy.

SPEAKER_01 30:22

Hope is not a strategy. Don't don't hope that the load shows up in a in a day or two. Don't don't hope that it's not a bad guy. Act as though it is. Act as though you're you're dealing with a theft. And if it ends up not being a theft, that's great. That's a good day. And you've actually, if it ends up not being a theft, you've actually done some training for your team, right? You've actually done some uh, you know, really quick in-the-moment training for your response team to see how they respond and see if they get the information they need and see if they call the right people and take the right actions. Time is really of the essence with cargo theft. You know, uh, our team, we work to investigate cargo thefts on behalf of our clients and we encourage them, hey, we're on call 24-7, 365. And we have to almost convince them, like we really mean that. Call me at 2:30 in the morning if that's when things seem to be going wrong. I will answer the phone or I will call you back immediately. Because if you wait till seven in the morning, that could make a huge difference. I I, you know, several months ago I recovered a load of metal for a client. And by the at the moment that I was able to get law enforcement to roll up on it, they were offloading the freight. So 30 minutes later, we may not have gotten that load back, right? So that's how close and how tight it can be. And so the minute it feels like something's going wrong, you have to act like it is. And if it ends up being fine, that's great. And you've, like I said, you've had some real life training on how to respond. So develop that spidey sense with your team. The minute it feels like it's going wrong, act as though it has. Unfortunately, in today's environment, that's how we have to deal with cargo theft because they're moving this stuff out of the country so quickly now that, and they're hiding it so well. They launder it on paper, they move it through crosstocks, they move it through transloading in lots, they they switch trucks, they switch locations. It's over and over again that it becomes so hard to find it if you're not responding while the theft is occurring. Your chances are really going to drop. So we have, you know, myself over the years, our team, we've had great success when the clients call us in that moment, right? And we can scramble with them. And we always tell the clients if it ends up not being a theft, you know, their their concern is always, well, we don't want to waste your time. You're not wasting my time. This is what I'm here to do, first of all. And second of all, if it turns out to not be a theft, we're all happy and we're all high-five in each other and we're we're we're good to go anyway. So, but time is of the essence.

SPEAKER_00 32:59

Uh for a lot of IT teams, they'll do tests, you know, internally with phishing emails and just to test to see if their employees pass or fail. Does that exist with cargo crime as well?

SPEAKER_01 33:09

Yeah. Yeah. Uh we're seeing a lot of that in the industry. Um

SPEAKER_00 33:13

like internal security teams are testing.

SPEAKER_01 33:15

Yeah, it's funny. Even my company, we we, you know, we do that. I'm sure you know, any any company nowadays is doing that. And I fail every once in a while, right? And and it's probably because I'm moving too fast, or or you know, you name it. And I always get that call from my boss of really you of all people, right? And even if it's once a year. So nobody's perfect, I guess, is what I'm saying with that, right? You would a lot of people would go, Well, I bet he never fails. Well, I I do, right? And some of them are just so good, but it doesn't change the fact that you just have to constantly reinforce that. And there has to be something behind that. Meaning, if you fail, like for me, if I fail, I have to take a course. It's a 15-minute course, but I have to take a course. That's a reminder, a refresher. I think that's appropriate, right? I think, I think there has to be something that reinforces constantly that culture around, you know, you shouldn't be clicking on these things. Here's how you identify them. We are all moving very quickly and specific in life in general, but specifically in the supply chain, everything's moving quickly. And it's easy for somebody to in, you know, inadvertently click on something that they shouldn't have because it seems very pertinent to the moment, or it seems to have all the common language that you see every day in the emails that you deal with every day. And again, this comes back to the just slow down just a little bit. Just slow down just a little bit now on the front end and pay more attention to those things.

SPEAKER_00 34:44

Because they're even get they're getting so smart. I saw this example with uh The Guardian and how somebody made a mock-up of the Guardian website and just use the Latin version of the I instead of the real I. And it if you're moving fast, there's no way you're gonna catch something like that.

SPEAKER_01 35:01

We see things like two lowercase Ns next to each other, so it looks like a lowercase M. We see all sorts of these things. And you know, when you're moving quickly, that I recognition is just similar enough that you're gonna you're gonna you're gonna go with it. And I think, you know, the FMCSA just put out some alerts recently about phishing emails going out where they're actually impersonating the FMCSA. And we've seen that in the past. We've seen them send out messages saying, hey, you have to uh change your password or you have to log in and and verify your information, those types of things. And the FMCSA has been putting out alerts and showing examples, which I think is really good on their part, showing examples of what some of those phishing emails or social engineering attempts look like. So kudos to them. I I would say that this is the most aggressive FMCSA administration that I've ever seen when it comes to dealing with cargo theft and fraud and all the different elements that we're trying to deal with. You know, uh certainly the federal government is a big ship and it takes a while to turn sometimes, you know, but that's the same thing with big corporations as well. But I do think that they're doing a really they're making a really strong effort to work with the industry. I will say, too, that this is the most communicative for sure. They show up at the TAPA conferences, they show up at the at the Texas Summit, they show up at the Midwest conference, they're, you know, so they're out there participating, Matt's, they're speaking, they're collaborating, they're reaching out. I've I've gone to DC several times and met with the FMCSA because they're just asking for opinions, asking for expertise. So uh kudos to them for what they're trying to do.

SPEAKER_00 36:36

And so uh I want to go back to your earlier point because I I think this ties it all in kind of nicely, or not nicely, but uh more awareness around it. But what if go if cargo crime has become so globalized where they can target different areas of the country, and considering that you know the overwhelming majority of the trucking companies in the country are, you know, 90%, I think, or maybe 92% have seven trucks or fewer. If what are the resources that those the the little guys can have? Because I mean, we we've talked a lot about internal security teams and IT teams. A lot of companies don't have those kind of resources. That's a great point. What happens with them? What resources do you know of that maybe exist for them?

SPEAKER_01 37:16

Well, there are a lot of resources out there. You know, when you when you look at some of the different platforms, the first thing I would say is make yourself as plainly known as you can, meaning, you know, uh be an open book to your business partners. Um, if they ask you to do some extra verification, do that extra verification. It will get you extra business, right? The more cooperative the smaller trucking companies can be with the verification process and participating in securing the load and communicating around security procedures and things like that at the point of pickup, the more business you're gonna get because the free brokers are gonna remember hey, this, you know, this company, they get it. They understand that cargo theft is a problem and they want to be very open with us and they're a great partner. And so they just they go through the verification process for us and they don't they don't push back on us with it. And and listen, I get it for the I grew up in trucking. Uh my first job at high school was driving a box truck, and then I drove a flatbed and things like that to help pay my way through college. So I get it. I I get it. I truly get it from the driver's standpoint. You're being asked to move quickly, you're being asked to move freight, you know.

SPEAKER_00 38:22

Invasion of privacy, that sort of debate too.

SPEAKER_01 38:25

And I get it. And and it's a it's a it's a struggle. And I guess it's gonna be a different answer and a different level of willingness for every person. But I would say the more cooperative you can be, the more participatory you can be in a security process with your business partners, certainly I think the more business you're going to get. I think also that, you know, when it comes to tech, the it tech is relatively affordable now. And especially if you are a one, you know, one truck show or a four, four or five truck show, that's a lot lower spend. Now it's it's all relevant, right? Income to to spend, I get that too, but but it's very affordable. If I if I take tracking, if I just use tracking as an example, when tracking first came out, it was the size of a brick and it was six thousand dollars and it was awful. It was awful. It was some of the worst tracking technology out there. Now it's 50 bucks. It's you know, it fits in a pill bottle, and a driver could put that in their own equipment, right? Or a driver could, if they're there at the point of loading, they could put it in the freight and and and advertise that as, hey, my loads are tracked and I'll give you access to the tracking. And the driver themselves can track it right from their phone or their tablet. And it's very affordable, uh, right. There are, you know, when you look at the different verification platforms that are out there: verified carrier, highway, freight verify, uh, truckstop.com, rims. I'm trying rimus, I'm trying to be fair and mention them all, right? But, you know, participate in those, get verified through those so that you already have the blue check mark, so to speak, people already know that you're a trusted entity, things like that. Ask those questions. What else can I do to make you comfortable with with us to get us regular volume, right? Um, I have a very close friend who I think they have three or four trucks, and they're actually going back to our earlier conversation, advertising the fact that, hey, we're about to get uh TSR certified through TAPA, trucking certain trucking security requirements certified through TAPA, right? So we'll be more secure than most of our peers. And again, only four, four or five trucks, right? And they're putting tracking in their trucks, and they have high security rear door locks that are really good for preventing pilferage or break-ins. They use uh uh seal locks to protect their perishable loads because they do some reefer, right? So they're using high-end security uh seal locks to protect the seal integrity. All that probably costs them, you know, the locks altogether probably cost them 300 bucks per truck. And the tracking, like I said, 50 bucks and a $10 a month or $15 a month subscription. I get it that every penny counts, but they're also getting better business now. They're getting higher rates, right? And they're getting consistent business from companies who are looking for those certifications and those process and procedures. So I do think that the small trucking companies can really find a niche in this industry, especially in this cargo theft environment where they can market themselves as being very secure. And it really is, you know, if you think about the really big trucking companies that have 14,000 trucks, that's a huge spend to secure 14,000 trucks or even a third of your fleet. But if you have three or four, if you can set aside just enough money to do that, you can actually make that back, you could have a really good return on investment in that and get some really consistent work with consistent lanes and consistent customers.

SPEAKER_00 42:02

Yeah, that no, that that's great insight and perspective because I think it all just kind of boils down to what can you do to create that level of safety and trust with your customers so you don't lose their business and you earn more of it. I've even heard of drivers that are stopping by different manufacturers and with their own like little box of donuts, and they're gonna go and introduce themselves to that facility so that they can put that face to a name instead of you know trying to get a you know a manufacturer to pay attention to their email, which they're probably not paying as close of attention to as somebody who's gonna come and knock on the door.

SPEAKER_01 42:36

Absolutely, you have to you have to differentiate yourself. It's no different than applying for a job, right? Why what's gonna make you stick out in the interview process? If they're interviewing 10 candidates, how do you make yourself the one?

SPEAKER_00 42:46

And so as we kind of round out this conversation, is there anything that you feel is important to mention that we haven't already talked about?

SPEAKER_01 42:53

I think it kind of it kind of goes back to one of the last questions you asked, but I think it's it's really critical. I stress this very often. You have to have a plan. If you have a theft, you have to have a plan. So certainly let's start with planning to not have a theft. Let's let's put the process and procedures in place and the right technology and all that, and let's make it all work together. But there's a there's a decent chance in this environment that you're going to have a theft. The bigger you are, the bigger that chance becomes as well. So I would say you have to have a plan way before the theft happens of what you will do when the theft occurs? Does everybody know what their function is? Does everybody know what their job is? Have you trained your team on it? You know, we we teach our clients to do desktop exercises, meaning come in one day and pretend like you have a theft and see how your team responds to it. Do they know who to call? Does everybody know what their job is in that role? Uh if if person A doesn't pick up the phone, will person B pick up the phone? Will person C pick up the phone? So test your process. But you have to have a process for the day that you have a theft. Because if you have a theft and you don't have that process, I promise you it will not go well.

SPEAKER_00 44:12

Because you'll lose all of that valuable time. And I think that that is um a a great place to leave it because you you've shared a lot of knowledge today and deeply appreciate your time. Where can folks connect with you, maybe get involved? Find me on LinkedIn.

SPEAKER_01 44:26

Easy, just search my name on LinkedIn. I'm there. I'm

SPEAKER_00 44:28

not sure.

SPEAKER_01 44:28

Don't try to

SPEAKER_00 44:29

impersonate you though.

SPEAKER_01 44:30

No, I'm always happy to interact with people. And I always say this too, you know, I've been doing this so long now uh that I'm just at a point where anybody, I'll help anybody against the bad guys at this point, right? So if you if you do have a problem, certainly if you're not a client, I can't investigate it for you. But people reach out to me every day, whether it's through LinkedIn or somebody gives them my phone number and hey, we had a theft, and I will I will connect you with the right resources, I will point you in the right direction, I will give you some advice. I just think it's the right thing to do. You know, opportunities like this to get the word out and just share information with the industry. I really appreciate you having me today. But uh, um, you know, if you need me, I'm not hard to find.

SPEAKER_00 45:10

Scott, thank you so much for the conversation and great insight too.

SPEAKER_01 45:14

Thanks.

SPEAKER_00 45:14

Thank you. Thank you so much for tuning in to this special edition from CargoRecs. This is one of many series that we have planned. So if you have a chance to check out more of our content, please do hit the subscribe button. It helps a lot with growing the channel. And then also, if you want to support more content like this, head on over to cargorex.io and consider becoming a premium or plus member. Offers a lot of benefits, all listed over on the website. Just hit the pricing tab over on the website and you can get signed up and even possibly be featured in one of these interviews just like this. Thank you so much.

About the Author

Blythe (Brumleve) Milligan
Blythe (Brumleve) Milligan
Creative entrepreneur in logistics. Founder of Digital Dispatch, CargoRex, and host of Everything is Logistics. Co-Founder at Jax Podcasters Unite. Previously: Board member of Transportation Marketing and Sales Association, Freightwaves on-air personality. Annoying Jaguars fan.

To read more about Blythe, check out her full bio here.